Case Study for KCl Softening: Priddis Greens Golf and Country Club Recycled Water Irrigation Research Project
By T.L. Roberts, Ph.D., K.R. Polizotto, Ph.D., and Sidney S. Blair
Summary: The following report offers an interesting new look at the benefits of potassium chloride (KCl) as a softener regenerant, as well as the merits of taking steps to maximize the efficiency of the softening process in reducing sodium and chlorides in the environment.
The Priddis Greens Golf and Country Club was established southwest of Calgary, Alberta, over a six year period, from 1985 to 1991. It’s one of Canada’s premier golf courses, having hosted the LPGA du Maurier Classic tournament in 1999.
A housing development associated with Priddis Greens contains 116 residential units that are dependent on the Priddis Greens Services Co-op for both water supply and disposal of their wastewater products. The water supply comes from a well on the property that’s fed by aquifers and service water from Priddis Creek, which flows nearby.
The recycled water from the residential units is used for irrigating nine holes of the golf course. In 1994, the golf course superintendent noticed turf grass receiving water from the recycled water holding pond was not growing as well as portions of the course receiving water from a nearby reservoir. After a water analysis, he suspected sodium discharge from residential water softeners was causing high sodium levels and high conductivity in the recycled water used for irrigation—and that this was causing the problems with turf growth on certain parts of the golf course.
The well water analysis is shown in Table 1.
From salt to potassium
In 1994, Priddis Greens Service Co-Op contacted a potassium chloride supplier with questions regarding softening water regenerated with potassium chloride. The supplier saw this as an opportunity to study the effect of how making a switch from sodium chloride (NaCl) to potassium chloride (KCl) would affect the sodium levels in water collected from a whole community. Researchers knew it would be essentially impossible to remove all of the sodium from the community, but wanted to know how much of the sodium was coming from softeners.
The following year, Priddis Greens removed all softeners from the homes in their residential community and installed a large central softening system regenerated with KCl at its water utility plant to supply residents and the club house with soft water. Elements of the central softening system included two 240,000 grain exchange capacity softeners, each containing approximately eight cubic feet of resin. Other notes:
- Softener efficiency was approximately 2,800 (grains of hardness removed per pound of KCl),
- Average KCl use per regeneration: 30.72 kilograms (kg) or 67.5 pounds (lbs)
- 8.4 pounds of KCl was needed to regenerate 1 cubic foot of resin
- Average monthly consumption of KCl: 1,490 kg or 3,278 lbs
- Approximate annual consumption of KCl: 17,780 kg or 39,336 lbs
Residential well comparison
To evaluate the change, soil and water samples were taken prior to the switch to KCl, and then again after three years. Following are results comparing residential well water analyses in 1995 and 1998.
- Potassium increased from 1.6 to 217 mg/L.
- Increase in TDS is due to the ion exchange of calcium and magnesium with potassium.
- Potassium has a higher equivalent weight. Each calcium ion is replaced with 1.95 potassium ions and each magnesium ion is replaced with 3.22 potassium ions.
- Hardness was reduced from 16.6 to 1.6 grains.
- Small decrease in sodium in the softened water indicates the potassium on the resin was removing some sodium from the well water.
- An unexpected increase in chlorides could have resulted from improper rinsing of the resin after regeneration.
Recycled water comparison
The Priddis Greens sewage treatment plant upgrades sewage water to a recycled water quality that’s suitable for irrigation. The recycled water is then stored in a 7.2 million gallon earthen reservoir and is used to irrigate the north portion of the golf course.
Over the four-year period, from 1994 to 1998 following the conversion from residential to central softening and the switch from NaCl to KCl as a regenerant a number of positive changes occurred in the ion content of the recycled water used for irrigation (see Table 2). Among the most significant that can be attributed to central softening are:
- Conductivity dropped 60.3 percent,
- TDS dropped 53.5 percent,
- Chlorides dropped 86.0 percent,
- pH dropped 6.25 percent, and
- Total alkalinity dropped 22.5 percent.
These changes are due to the increase in softening efficiency when Priddis Greens went to central softening. The individually-operated residential softeners contributed significantly to the build up of an undesirable ion content in the recycled water due to use of older, inefficient softeners; oversetting of softeners by homeowners, which resulted in unused salt winding up in recycled water; and use of time clock softeners rather than demand initiated regeneration (DIR) units, which contributed to the overall inefficiency. A follow-up research project is under way at the Windstone Golf Club in North Barrington, Ill., the objective of which is to determine whether similar results can be achieved by having the homeowners use properly set DIR KCl-regenerated softeners.
Other positive changes in the recycled water attributable to a combination of the switch to KCl and central softening include that the fact that sodium content fell by 82.4 percent. By calculation, this can be broken down as follows:
- Sodium reduction due to KCl softening—51 mg/L, or 20% of total loss.
- Sodium reduction due to central softening—209 mg/L, or 80% of total loss.
In addition, potassium content in the recycled water increased from 35 mg/L to 107 mg/L—over 300 percent. Since potassium is a major plant nutrient, when the golf course was irrigated with this water, it received additional potassium. This contribution has been calculated and has subsequently reduced the fertilizer program cost.
Both of the above are very positive changes when evaluating the use of recycled water for irrigation.
Soil analysis comparison
Soil analysis prior to and after introduction of KCl water softening are show in Table 3.
Soil samples were taken in the summer of 1995 and in the fall of 1998 from the 9th holes of the south and north courses in the fairway approximately 150 yards before the green. The south course is irrigated with surface water and the north course with recycled water from the treatment plant lagoon. Soil samples were also taken from a grassed rough area on the 5th hole (north course). The soil near the 5th hole has not been irrigated and provides a general background level of soil characteristics in the Priddis area and an indication of the changes to the soil due to irrigation, whether with waste or surface water.
On the south course, there was little change in extractable cations. Soil pH and cation exchange capacity increased but this could be due to a sample site variation. Available potassium decreased from 448 ppm to 310 ppm—or 30.8 percent.
In the north course, the change to potassium softened water led to the following changes in the 0-to-6 inch layer of soil:
- Extractable potassium nearly tripled.
- Available potassium jumped by two-thirds.
- Extractable sodium remained constant.
When the project was initiated, the turf grass receiving recycled water wasn’t growing as well as areas irrigated with surface water. James Beebe, Priddis Greens golf course manager, indicated growth of the affected turf returned to normal with the switch to KCl as a regenerant. The decrease in TDS, chlorides and sodium and the increase in potassium in the recycled water combined to produce a very positive effect on the turf.
Develop an education program to promote the advantages of using KCl as a water softening regenerant, i.e., it reduces chloride by 12-to-20 percent, doesn’t add sodium to the ecosystem and does add potassium—a major plant nutrient. This approach has been used by Santa Barbara and Monterey County, which have developed mailers that go out with the utility bill and pamphlets that can be handed out at home shows, trade shows, etc.
The WateReuse Association of California, Pacific Water Quality Association and the water conditioning dealers should work together to develop a program that would target existing water conditioning units. The objective would be to promote the proper setting of existing softeners to reduce excess salt going into the wastewater system.
This would involve a public relations campaign to have water conditioning dealers contact their customers and encourage people with softeners to contact their dealers to have softeners set at the most efficient setting. The promotion would involve both organizations, the water utility and the dealer. It also could look at offering an incentive to promote upgrading existing time clock softeners to demand initiated regeneration.
Such a cooperative effort could be an excellent program for the Water Quality Association to promote beyond California’s borders. Involving recycled water providers, dealers and homeowners to promote the efficient use of water softeners would dramatically improve the overall quality of recycled water used in irrigation and would, hopefully, avoid confrontational legislation restricting the use of softeners.
Positive legislation can help, such as California Senate Bill 1006 passed last fall which requires that: 1) All new residential softeners sold after Jan. 1, 2000 have to be either DIR or use portable exchange tanks and meet a salt efficiency standard of 3,350 grains of hardness removed per pound of regenerant, and 2) the efficiency standard will move to 4,000 grains in January 2002.
The above article was presented to Agriculture Committee of the Water Reuse Foundation, on Feb. 2, 2000. Special thanks from the authors go to Bill Wist, PCS Technical Services, and the staff of Priddis Greens Golf Course.
About the authors
Dr. Terry L. Roberts is vice president of the Potash Phosphate Institute in Atlanta, Ga. He can be reached at (770) 447-0335 or email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Dr. Kim R. Polizotto is chief agronomist for PCS Sales of Saskatoon, Saskatchewan. He can be reached at (306) 933-8544 or email: email@example.com
Sidney S. Blair is president of Kaleidoscope Systems Inc. His bachelor’s degree in agriculture and his master’s in soil science and plant nutrition are from the University of Saskatchewan. He’s worked as a soil fertility extension specialist in agronomy and sales management for the J.R. Simplot Company and, for 19 years, in sales management with the Potash Corporation of Saskatchewan. He’s currently in the second year of a two-year contract with Morton Salt to assist with marketing its new potassium-based water softening regenerant. Blair is a member of the Agriculture Institute of Canada, American Society of Agronomy, Soil Science Society of America, American Water Works Association, Water Quality Association and WateReuse Association. He can be reached at (306) 653-1028, (306) 665-0134 (fax) or email: firstname.lastname@example.org